LOS ANGELES, CA — California’s property insurance crunch is no longer confined to wildfire-prone canyons and mountain slopes. It is now reaching new suburbs in the Inland Empire, where homebuyers in lower-risk areas are finding that standard coverage is harder to secure, more expensive or both.
That shift is turning insurance into a deal-breaking issue for buyers who thought they were moving into safer territory. In some neighborhoods, families shopping for newly built homes are being pushed toward the state-backed FAIR Plan, which covers only fire, or toward surplus lines insurers that operate outside California’s regular consumer protections.
A New House in Menifee Came With a Coverage Problem
Tech worker Alex Hwang and his wife were buying a new six-bedroom house in Pulte’s Cimarron Ridge development, a $700,000 home in the Inland Empire, after leaving the expensive Bay Area. The couple expected insurance to be a routine part of closing, especially because the builder normally helps arrange it.
Instead, as the closing date approached, they were told no comprehensive policy could be found in the standard market. The options that remained did not fit a lender’s requirements, because one excluded fire coverage. Hwang said the only practical choices were the FAIR Plan, plus a separate policy for the rest of the house, or a surplus lines policy he had never heard of before.
He ended up choosing the surplus lines route, but only after accepting a $25,000 fire deductible. “I hate the $25,000, but I didn’t really have a whole lot of choice,” he said.
FAIR Plan Growth Is Moving Beyond the Highest Fire Zones
A Los Angeles Times analysis of state data found that the FAIR Plan is expanding fastest not only in the state’s most dangerous fire areas, but also in low- to moderate-risk ZIP Codes. In 396 ZIP Codes, nine out of 10 policies added to the plan between March 2025 and the end of June 2026 were classified by the plan itself as low-risk.
That added 11,000 homes to a program that already covered 138,000 low-risk properties rejected by the regular market. The pattern is especially visible in the Inland Empire, where sprawling housing developments have grown along the Interstate 215 corridor and insurers have backed away even where the surrounding landscape is mostly sparse brush and sage rather than dense forest.
Near Menifee, FAIR Plan policies increased fivefold from 2024 to June. In Hemet, they rose 660%, with more than 1,100 new policies in a single ZIP Code.
Families Are Choosing Between Bare Bones Fire Coverage and Unregulated Policies
Homebuyers and brokers describe a market where the normal choice has disappeared. The FAIR Plan offers only partial fire protection, so many owners must buy a second policy to cover the rest of the home. Surplus lines insurers may provide broader coverage, but they do so outside the state’s regulated market.
That means California regulators cannot control their rates or handle complaints in the same way they can for admitted carriers. If a surplus lines company fails, policyholders do not get the backup protection provided by the state guarantee fund that supports regulated insurers.
According to Weiss Ratings, surplus lines carriers now make up 7% of California’s home insurance market, up from 1% in 2021. The shift has created a market where buyers are increasingly forced to accept deductibles and exclusions they did not expect when they started house hunting.
Lara Says the Market Is Stabilizing, But Data Show a Wider Retreat
Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara told lawmakers in June that California’s insurance market was showing signs of stabilization, pointing to a slowdown in the pace of policies entering the FAIR Plan. But state records reviewed by the Times tell a more complicated story.
The analysis found that conventional homeowners insurance remains scarce across large parts of the state, including the Inland Empire. Since the market peaked in 2016, 1,300 ZIP Codes have lost 462,000 policies. The state now has fewer traditional home insurance policies than at any point in the last 15 years.
Insurers say they have been unable to raise rates quickly enough to keep up with rebuilding costs, labor and wildfire losses. In 2024, State Farm and Farmers announced plans to drop tens of thousands of customers, while other major carriers stopped taking new ones altogether.
Specialty Carriers Are Filling the Gap, but Often at a Price
As traditional insurers retreat, specialty carriers are taking their place. Some of the biggest growth has come through surplus lines companies, including Allstate’s unregulated North Light Specialty line, which expanded after Allstate stopped writing new business in California through its regulated carrier in 2022.
Other players include companies based in hurricane-prone Florida and newer firms such as Indiana-based Orion180 and Nebraska startup Summit Specialty. Hwang’s policy came from Summit Specialty, which has an A rating from AM Best but a negative outlook. If it were to fail, his coverage would not be backed by California’s guarantee fund.
Another Riverside County buyer, a man identified only as Louis, said he and his wife were also unable to get a lender-required policy on a $700,000 home east of Murrieta until they accepted a surplus lines option. Their policy carried a $14,000 fire deductible, and he said the experience left him wondering whether he could afford both the house and the insurance.
Brokers Say Insurance Is Now the First Hurdle in Buying a Home
For brokers working in the Inland Empire, the insurance hunt has become a central part of the homebuying process. Riverside broker Bob Severns said insurance used to be the last box buyers checked before closing. Now it is often the first question they have to solve.
That change is reshaping new construction in one of California’s fastest-growing housing markets. Experts say the surplus lines market is keeping deals alive for now, but it is also masking how many buyers are being pushed into policies that are thinner, more expensive or both.
Severns and other brokers say they can usually find something for buyers willing to keep looking. The bigger question, they say, is whether families can absorb the price.
More on what homes, rents and new builds are doing near you, on RHS Commoner.
